I just went through this recently. Never bothered to look for replacements yet but the OEM screws are a special made for plastic screw. If I remember correctly, the closest I could find was a numbered size, not fractional....ei, #10, not 1/4. But as mentioned the sheet metal screws have quite a bit more diameter or well too small depending on the size you compare it to. I have seen these plastic screws in tons of other plastics before, you can always tell too because they have that double spiral where the one is small and close to the core, and the other is larger and flared out. I think the plastic screws are also used on the fiberglass such as the filler neck flange and where the nose cover on the SJ screws onto the handlepole location just above the engine cover hood hooks. I will have to find something eventually, when I do I will post up the results.