Surfriding Forget Sharks—Cows Are More Likely To Kill You

OCD Solutions

Original, Clean and Dependable Solutions
Location
Rentz, GA
Actually, you could argue that deer are more likely to kill you than any other animal (apart from your fellow man), at least in the U.S. According to “11 animals more likely to kill you than sharks,” an oft-repeated Mother Nature Network article on the internet, the most likely animals to kill you, are 1) mosquitoes, 2) hippos, 3) deer, 4) bees, 5) dogs, 6) ants, 7) jellyfish, 8) cows, 9) horses, 10) spiders, and 11) rattlesnakes. On average, < 1 person per year is killed by a shark in the U.S. (and < 6 worldwide).

The article referenced above doesn’t limit its listed killers to the U.S., and some of its assertions are debatable. For example, it’s not the mosquito itself that kills people, but a species of Plasmodium, a microorganism that infects female mosquitoes and causes malaria when introduced to a person’s bloodstream via a mosquito bite. Similarly, the article lists deer as the number 3 killer, but the actual cause of death is the result of drivers hitting deer with their cars. If we restrict the list to U.S. deaths and omit mosquitoes and deer, the listing becomes 1) bees (53 deaths each year in the U.S.), 2) dogs (30-35 deaths), 3) cows (22), 4) horses (20), 5) spiders (6.5), and 6) rattlesnakes (5.5). Yep – you are 10 times more likely to die in the U.S. because of a bee sting than a bite from a rattler and 22 times more likely to be killed by a cow than by a shark.

Using statistics from the Center for Disease Control, J.A. Forrester, C.P. Holstege, and J.D. Forrester conducted a more scientific investigation of human fatalities from animals in the U.S. (“Fatalities From Venomous and Nonvenomous Animals in the United States (1999-2007),” published in Wilderness and Environmental Medicine, June 2012). “The CDC WONDER Database was queried to return all animal-related fatalities between 1999 and 2007. Rates for animal-related fatalities were calculated using the estimated 2003 US population. Inclusion criteria included all mortalities that were a consequence of bite, contact, attack, or envenomation…There were 1802 animal-related fatalities with the majority coming from nonvenomous animals (60.4%). The largest percentage (36.4%) of animal-related fatalities was attributable to “other mammals,” which is largely composed of farm animals.”

The results of the study by Forrester et al. for the 7-year period, from highest to lowest (source), are:

  • #1. The number of deaths that resulted from interactions with other mammals, a category that includes cats, cows, horses, pigs, raccoons, and other hoofed animals: 655. The biggest bringers of death are cows and horses.
  • #2. The number of deaths that resulted from interactions with hornets, wasps, or bees: 509.
  • #3. The number of deaths that resulted from interactions with dogs: 250.
  • #4. The number of deaths that resulted from interactions with nonvenomous insects or nonvertebrates: 85.
  • #5. The number of deaths that resulted from interactions with non-venomous reptiles. This would include lizards and non-venomous snakes and the cause of death being bitten or crushed by the animal: 77.
  • #6. The number of deaths that resulted from interactions with venomous spiders: 70.
  • #7. The number of deaths that resulted from other venomous arthropods such as fire ants: 63.
  • #8. The number of deaths that resulted from interactions with venomous snakes or lizards: 59.
  • #9. The number of deaths that resulted from interactions with marine animals: 10, 8 of them from sharks.
  • #10. The number of deaths that resulted from interactions with crocodiles and alligators: 9.
The study concluded by stating: “Prevention measures aimed at minimizing injury from animals should be directed at certain high-risk groups such as farmworkers, agricultural workers, and parents of children with dogs.” “A disproportionate number of fatalities result from animal encounters in the South. This region is one that could possibly benefit from improved education about risky animal encounters, as well as legislation to reduce potentially fatal encounters. Interactions in the agricultural environment, preventive techniques and rapid treatment for those exposed to hornets, wasps, and bees, and preventing encounters between children and potentially aggressive canines represent 3 possible arenas for improvement.”

Article by Bill Norrington

http://www.geog.ucsb.edu/events/department-news/1195/forget-sharks-cows-are-more-likely-to-kill-you/
 
How much time does one spend around a dog compared to a shark? If we all hung out floating in the ocean 12 hours a day that data would be completely different.
 

Vumad

Super Hero, with a cape!
Location
St. Pete, FL
How much time does one spend around a dog compared to a shark? If we all hung out floating in the ocean 12 hours a day that data would be completely different.

I live in pinellas county. People are floating around in the water here near sharks for about 12 hours every single day.
 

naticen

Site Supporter
Location
wilmington, nc
I don't think so. Beaches are packed with thousands of people on any given day, or littered with lone surfers for 12 hours a day. Similar, in my opinion, to not everyone has dogs or even sees dogs every day. Sharks rarely bite people and even less often kill. I'm more scared of a loose dog than a shark, even if that fear is very slight to nonexistent.

Some surfer just got bit here last week, which is rare, and got some stitches in his hand. It would be hard to say that shark had any intentions of eating or killing that guy or he would have no hand. I have literally surfed, downstream, right next to an old buddy chumming up the water and reeling in sharks purposefully.

I remember reading once that coconuts falling out of trees kill 14 people a year which is more than sharks.
 
Ok, I see your points...but being a beach bum is not the same as floating in deep shark water most of your life. We have figured out how to keep sharks out of ocean beaches open to the public enough to make it minimal. The reason I brought this up is because many dog owners sleep in the same rooms as them and are actually around them about 15+ hours a day.

With a dog you are in the belly of the beast constantly. If you make that thing snap it will attack. Where in the water front available to ocean enthusiast the chance of an aggressive encounter has been minimized greatly.
 

naticen

Site Supporter
Location
wilmington, nc
I spear fish with a stringer of fish at my hip. Sharks will try to steal it if you let them near you, but still avoid biting your hip 6" away. People will stick a dog treat in your BC by your neck to mess with you and get sharks sniffing up on you. You can't get much more in their world asking for it than that and I have not experienced any problems.
 

OCD Solutions

Original, Clean and Dependable Solutions
Location
Rentz, GA
I agree 100%. You start bringing sharks into your home, life and bed, those numbers are going to change exponentially. Ever try to take a shark on a walk? You're ahead of the curve if you can manage to get the leash done up without losing a hand much less make it once around the block.
 
I spear fish with a stringer of fish at my hip. Sharks will try to steal it if you let them near you, but still avoid biting your hip 6" away. People will stick a dog treat in your BC by your neck to mess with you and get sharks sniffing up on you. You can't get much more in their world asking for it than that and I have not experienced any problems.


Because its going for the familiar fish it sees all the time dead on a stick while it stalks the water/air line. It's going for the familiar and safe meal over the threat of a human. We can put you in a field with a few cows or deep in to shark ocean and have you kick and float with a yellow life vest.....its your choice, which would you feel safer in?

The point is exposure here and since the data does not distinguish the vacuum that is the exposed environment to the animal I would rather roll around with unfamiliar doggies all day than spend the same amount of time without power floating with sharks.
 

Vumad

Super Hero, with a cape!
Location
St. Pete, FL
Ok, I see your points...but being a beach bum is not the same as floating in deep shark water most of your life. We have figured out how to keep sharks out of ocean beaches open to the public enough to make it minimal. The reason I brought this up is because many dog owners sleep in the same rooms as them and are actually around them about 15+ hours a day.

With a dog you are in the belly of the beast constantly. If you make that thing snap it will attack. Where in the water front available to ocean enthusiast the chance of an aggressive encounter has been minimized greatly.

Wow, have you been lured into a sort of false sense of security about sharks while being manipulated into an unjustified paranoia of dogs.

The idea that we are somehow keeping sharks out of beach swim areas is absolutely absurd. It's very easy to find examples of very large sharks near people...

abc_gma_shark_110903_wg.jpg


I don't think Katherine got the "No swimming" notification in our jet ski zone at the freeride.
http://www.natureworldnews.com/arti...te-shark-repeatedly-spotted-florida-coast.htm

Lots of other sharks missed the memo too.
http://abcnews.go.com/US/story?id=92630




Floating in deep shark water? Who does this? I agree completely that the death rate by sharks would go up dramatically if people regularly jumped off cruise ships and thrashed about for hours at a time. I would also agree that if you walk up to an African lion and punch it in the face, you will probably die in that case too.



Dogs are animals, but we are hardly in the belly of the beast at all times. If you want a fair comparison to floating in deep shark water, you need to get into a dog fighting ring with 3 pit bulls bread and trained to fight, and start punching them. The truth is, most dogs are minimally dangerous.

Comparing my Labrador to those pit bulls would be like comparing a nurse shark to a bull shark and saying anything that is a "shark" is viciously dangerous.

Edit: I know, I make long posts, I shortened it up.
 
Last edited:
My bottom line is simply that a shark is more likely to f*** you up given the chance than a dog or cow and no amount of data is going to change my mind. :p
 

naticen

Site Supporter
Location
wilmington, nc
Check out b_hunsucker on instagram. That guy was reeled in yesterday evening where we camp for the Carolina Freeride. Tell me that cute face would do you any harm. He just likes to hang out just like me and you.

BTW, you can just google "b_hunsucker instagram" to look at it even if you don't have an account.
 
Top Bottom