Both are great hulls, and as i have said on here a lot lately there are no bad hulls anymore only choices that may not be made perfectly by the riders. I have ridden and like the Q8 a lot. Joshs ski is almost perfect. That being said Brians Brawler is awesome also, perfect in the surf and as Chris has shown at the lake erie freeride easy to string tricks back to back. The question you need to ask yourself is where are you at in your current riding level?? How do you currently ride, rolls, stabs, flips, surf tricks or flat?