You are still wanting to know the beat surf hull right? I understand the meaning "all around" surf hull but you are focusing very heavily on carving hard without sliding and high speed riding without porpoising. I don't do any of that type of riding inbetween sets of chest to head high surf or even small surf. I'm not bashing your desire for those things but maybe a full length ski would better suit you. Some people like their surf skis to be very loose and nimble (I do personally) but if you want your ski to stay planted and be more predictable then I'd say try some full length versions of these hulls or maybe just stick with a Superjet. If you want lightweight then get a carbon superjet.
It's nice to get other peoples opinions but this is exactly why you are going to get advise that may not relate to your preferences. When I read your first post about a surf hull I didn't think you'd be so adamant about high speed turning and straight line speed without porpoising... That kinda changed my view as your perfect surf hull. Maybe I'm way off but that's how I see it
MB, if what you're after is a hull that carves f'n hard, sticks to the water like crazy, rails turns, does great turns and still feels light - look no further than the LWDE Revolution hull. It does all that superbly.