Other torn meniscus..

Anyone here have surgery for torn meniscus? if so, was it a pain afterwards/recovery etc? kinda busted my right knee up a few times during the week at daytona freeride. fig id wear a basic knee brace and wait it out some to see if it got better before goin to doc,but it didnt,i went last week and after the mri was told i had bad sprain on mcl and torn meniscus,having surgery on the 29th. really dont wanna lose the ski season again this year. i have a buddy who does ortho/prosthetics and trying to have him hook me up with a custom fitted cti knee brace. says it will help protect while riding. just looking for some input from anyone who went through this.. thanks.
 

wydopen

onthepipe
i had mine removed...

i won a mountain bike whip contest 4 days later..

if you are going to have it repaired you will be out for awhile unless u want to tear it again...have it snipped out i have had zero problems with it..
 

brandirad

Be Rad, Stay Rad
Location
Henderson, NV
I crashed my dirtbike and tore my acl and meniscus when I was 17. Had surgery, and after 6 months of physical therapy 3 times a week I was back riding the bike and playing varsity volleyball. That was four years ago and it really doesn't give me problems. It gets sore occasionally and I can tell when the weather is going to change because of the screws haha. Other than that it wasn't that bad as far as recovery in my opinion. But if you do surgery you will most likely miss out on riding season. I know sometimes they can do a surgery that kind of "band-aides" the problem for a few months then get it fixed completely, but I guess in the long run it makes things worse. I'm not sure. Check out as many options as possible.
 
Had my meniscus repaired 9 months ago after tearing it in the surf so bad my leg was stuck in a bent position and i couldnt put ANY weight on it, it sucked. Stayed in pismo for two days trying to figure out how to drive home(right knee,leg) to sac. What an adventure that weekend and subsequent following 7 month rehab.
There is a huge difference between a repair or just having the tear removed. Depending on if the meniscus just tore or if it was a bucket handle tear like I had you have two options. Mine tore but was still connected on both ends resembling the handle of a bucket. First option is to see how much tore, percent wise, and if there is a good chunk tore and it can be repaired(stitched back to the meniscus)then you have even more to think about Because the recovery time for repairing it is about a 5-6 week period that you can't put any weight on the treated leg and then months of rehab to help the meniscus hopefully connect as well as it can. The benefit about re attaching it if possible is that you pretty much have you entire meniscus. I had a bucket handle tear so I chose the re attachment method which was a long process but I chose that solely because I am 30 and I had such a big tear that I would have had arthritis soon.


luckily the orthopedic surgeon i was able to have do my surgery was dr. Akizuki and he is the sf giants team ortho doctor. Guy was super cool and I had the surgery around 5 p.m. And I was home by 10 having drinks with my buddies, but the next day and following weeks was sore as hell. If you can they rent little machines that you fill a reservoir with ice and water and it wraps around your leg and it pumps the cold water around your knee, waaaaaay worth the rental. Also the have a small device that sits on the couch and you strap your leg in it and it flexes your leg for you if you have the type of surgery that requires no weight bearing because since your sitting its not weight bearing. I sat on the couch and went through tons of ice and water and used the flex machine for hours a day, well worth it.


hopefully yours is just a minor tear and its super easy man, they cut it off and like Andrew said your back to winning bike whip contests. Good luck man, hope it goes well. I didn't ride for 6 months and hope you don't have do that either.

Ohh and worst part about the whole surgery was going back a month later and my knee was huge and doc drained the fluid from my knee, worst pain of my life and that's coming from someone who was kicked in the head by a horse lol
 

AtomicPunk

Lifetime bans are AWESOME
Site Supporter
Location
Largo, Fl
Ohh and worst part about the whole surgery was going back a month later and my knee was huge and doc drained the fluid from my knee, worst pain of my life and that's coming from someone who was kicked in the head by a horse lol


What I want to know is what where you doing to the horse??? :dance:

On second thought, nevermind.
 
Sitting here reading up while i'm recovering from my surgery I had this Wednesday for a completely torn ACL and a small tear in my meniscus. It really depends on how bad its messed up. Yeah, you can take them out and get back into the swing of things, but then your putting more stress on the rest of your ligaments and you don't have all the cushion you should. My meniscus was only torn, so they shaved part of it off and it should be good to go. Only downside is when they repair your meniscus they want you on crutches longer but I would believe its a shorter recovery time. Torn ACL or MCL you are probably looking at 6 months minimum (that's what I was told).

I advocate for both the CPM (motion machine mentioned above - helps you recover faster) as well as the ice pack that constantly flushes water through. Granted the oxycotton and norco help with the pain.
 
Trimming the meniscus and your pretty much back to activities in a couple weeks.

Repairing it and its a lengthy recovery, I was off my my leg for months, right about 6 months after surgery date I noticed it felt a lot better and that's when I went for my first ski ride.

Basically if you are a major athlete in a pro sport you would probably get it trimmed to get back only missing a few games/events. If it is a big tear and save able I would go for repairing it, at least that's what I did.
 
Moving feed off the ground into a raised feeder when I was younger, horse turned around and kicked me in the head, over 150 stitches, 1mm down would have lost my eye, 1mm deeper would have pierced the brain. Gnarly story ensues but won't thread jack, good luck with your leg
 
Location
LBI
Make sure you follow the PT and take your time. Make sure you focus on proper nutrition and supplementation, if you have any questions send me a PM, this is what I do for my career.

Best of luck!
 
thanks for info guys, im pretty sure they need to remove the torn section of meniscus, and the recovery wont be that bad (i hope). i was having flash backs of last july when i had sugery for one ruptured tendon and one torn on my shoulder/rotator cuff, that was a real nightmare of long recovery and still not 100%.
 

BruceSki

Formerly Motoman25
Location
Long Island
my pops had this surgery yesterday. He's doing pretty good already today. Obviously not recovering like he's 20, but doing well anyhow.

Go bang out the surgery and you'll be on the ski by the time the waters warm enough to enjoy riding.
 

JetManiac

Stoked
Site Supporter
Vendor Account
Location
orlando
I tore my ACL completely and had meniscus tears on each side of my knee after a wakeboarding injury. Recovery from surgery replacing ACL and trimming the meniscus tears was faster than I had expected but still took 6+ months to recover to decent physical condition. I was jetskiing after 2-3 months but not pushing it or riding hard.

Next was jet ski knee injury to same knee and again surgery for just meniscus tears. Rehab and recovery was much quicker and was riding again relatively quickly. As mentioned above by others, rehab is very important and will speed recovery and strengthen knee to help protect from future damage, but my experience is that post surgery knees will never be as heathly or strong and prone to reinjury especially if you are doing any extreme sports like freestyle/freeride jet skiing.
 

djkorn1

kidkornfilms
Site Supporter
Location
Cleveland Ohio
I had mine snipped about 5 weeks ago. In 3 weeks I was skiing moguls (probably the hardest thing you can possible do to your knees). I was walking that day. It still hurts a little bit when I kneel, but that is just the holes healing.

Very easy surgery. I basically felt better than before the surgery only 4 or 5 days later. Get it done.

They said I am too old to have mine repaired, so they just trimmed it.
 
Last edited:
I tore my ACL completely and had meniscus tears on each side of my knee after a wakeboarding injury. Recovery from surgery replacing ACL and trimming the meniscus tears was faster than I had expected but still took 6+ months to recover to decent physical condition. I was jetskiing after 2-3 months but not pushing it or riding hard.

Next was jet ski knee injury to same knee and again surgery for just meniscus tears. Rehab and recovery was much quicker and was riding again relatively quickly. As mentioned above by others, rehab is very important and will speed recovery and strengthen knee to help protect from future damage, but my experience is that post surgery knees will never be as heathly or strong and prone to reinjury especially if you are doing any extreme sports like freestyle/freeride jet skiing.

What type of graft did you use for your ACL?
 
Top Bottom