listen to Augustaf and verify your octane vs dome cc's and bore diameter with RIVA. mention your use case too: big hull that has lots of surface area in contact with water. Since you have been through this twice already maybe go back to stock compression until all other issues are ironed out.
The pic of the 82.75 shows 1 corner, is there scoring on the other 3 corners? If you can post pics of both pistons in the the 82.75 and 83 sets. Show all sides and the tops of all 4 pistons.
Good reading material here
http://www.groupk.com/tec-seizures.htm and here
http://www.groupk.com/tec-rearseize.htm
going 40:1 and dual cooling will not solve the root issue but will give you more margin for error. Groupk recommended 40:1 when a 701 was in the waverunner 2 hull
http://www.groupk.com/y753b2.htm GroupK also recommend 40:1 when a 650sx that was 50:1 stock is modified, 32:1 when a Factory Pipe is added
http://www.groupk.com/restof650k.htm . I have not ridden with anyone running a modified engine with less oil than 40:1. Maybe they are out there but 40:1 is much more common.