Not sure you will ever get a straight answer to this question bro. I hate it for you. I do hate to see people send BIG$ on hulls that go obsolete for them because they are to heavy or long to go big in flatwater or are to squirelly to chase boats on. I can honestly say I know peeps that bought an FS2 and love but wish it were lighter, seen people buy BOBs and couldnt sell it fast enough because they were misserable chasing boats and rec riding.
so...........
While you think right this second (i wont ever wanna flip in flatwater or do 360's in flatwater) you may have the desire soon after buying a Rickter.
If you choose a good, short, light hull that is well designed you will be able to do BOTH.
Its my opinion that the short -6.5 to -10" carbon freak badass hull is the best (from MY experience) all around hull made for doing BOTH.
A -5.5" will work but most I know wish for shorter in time.
The Backy Chan seems close as well, I do not have alot of time on it but the time I had on it was EASY and it controlled well at speed and seemed to hook up well.
KDX will work but it will take some serious getting used to for chasing boats down. It is a better flatwater freestyle hull than the freak badass but for that same reason it is squirelly on top.
Rickter's are awesome rec boats but IMO too heavy for flatwater unless you have serious power.
Your cannot go wrong with a carbon freak for a good mix, I feel the same about a back chan but cannot say that for sure until I have more time on one. I definately think its a boat you could easily get used to for both rec and freestyle thus far though. I would not hesitate to buy one if I needed one right now.
Hope this helps bro. I am not selling ANYONES product because of who they are, I am a rider like you who likes trying ALOT of different setups. I support what I like, not who I like.
EME hulls not rec but Q8 is a good freestyle hull stay away from a sky period
BOB not rec IMO but I have not tried a Gen 3 or Hurricane so maybe someone non bias can chime in on those
Trinity all I have seen were not flatwater worthy but fine for rec
ROK carbon hulls are super fun, glass hulls too heavy for flatwater great rec hulls but tough in rough water like inlets as they are nose down and tend to sub
ROK-R very little time on one but I could see where they would take some getting used to
Backy Chan very little time on one but seemed nice, stable and light as well as short enough for freestyle seemed noce all around
Freak Badass shorter the better IMO and go carbon period all carbon ones are nice -5.5 or more will give you a nice rec and freestyle combo and even a nice surf slasher
Rickters for flatwater I think it would take the ninja for me to be impressed, awesome rec boats for sure way better than an sj but just a great rec hull IMO
KDX awesome flatwater but would not want it for boat chasing or surf riding, that being said I WANT ONE FOR THE LOCAL RAMP BAD LOL
Freak Circus not enough time on one to comment, super short and fun at the ramp but no time rec riding yet so cannot really say
Wammer hull just an SJ bro, waste of time and $ IMO
Stunt All around nose plowing POS
In case my first post was not clear I figured I would break my thoughts down here in hopes it helps some. Hope no one hates on my thoughts as they are just that MY thoughts and thats what thios Forum is all about right.