its real easy to not tighten the prop all the way, just had this happen the other day with a new scat. its best to pull it apart and inspect the bearings to make sure they fell smooth, no grit or slop in them. and then find yourself a thread file or die to run over the threads on the shaft. then find a tap for the threads on the prop and clean that all up. then I like a good amount of blue loctite on the threads or you can use thread sealant( the white stuff) and slowly and gently spin the prop on just because you cant turn the prop anymore does not mean it was tight, it was stuck and not yet bottomed out. and that resulted in your sloppy loose shaft situation. I could be wrong but from what I see that is what I believe is your issue.
And dont worry I replace lots of props with sbt remans and never had any issues.