I will try to call you Tom if work allows.
I understand what all of you are saying, and agree to some point. But I don't have anyone locally who will look at my ski besides this guy, Its Dales Jet Sports, if any of you have heard of him. He used to race standups etc and has been in business for years.
So what i'm saying is he's seen my ski, started it, listened to it rev. I've made the arguements that ya'll are making, asked questions etc. To the point of boarderline insulting him by questioning his diagnosis. He's sure of it, I didn't want to pay him roughly $250 to do the labor when I know how to fix what he's diagnosing.
Also, the engine ran great with a stock FX-1 pump that it was previously attached to (less load). The only thing i've changed is the addtion of a 144 pump and this impeller (and a head, but they measured 165 & 175psi.) And the guy at Impros (can't rememeber his name, but super helpful) said that the number on the side of the prop is just a label, and confirming what you've mentioned, it probably isn't a 12/17 in reality. I will pull it out and measure the pitch and let ya'll know what it is.
I've tried a lot (A effing lot) of jetting/ N&S settings with my carb, tried other peoples carbs with different jetting combinitations to see if something is inherently wrong with my carb. None of it helped. The only thing I haven't changed is the impeller, and that was the one thing I changed from when the engine was in a 'known good' condition. I feel like a knuckle head for not trying this yet, I guess I didn't want to drop the cash on another impeller. I don't see any harm in throwing on a nice low pitch impeller and seeing what it does.
The other possible issue Dale suggested is binding in the driveline, but even if it was in fact binding I don't think react like this.
Once again, i'm hugely thankful for all the feedback ya'll have given me on this problem and I will defintely tell you if he's wrong. But I paid this guy good money to look at my ski. Whats the point if I ignore the diagnosis he gave me?